>Baker City Herald | Baker County Oregon's News Leader

Baker news NE Oregon Classifieds Web
web powered by Web Search Powered by Google

Follow BakerCityHerald.com

Baker City Herald print edition

view all Baker City Herald print publications »

The Baker City Herald is now online in a Replica E-edition form and publishes Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays. Current subscribers have full access to the E-edition.

View Paper

If you are not a current subscriber, subscribe today for immediate access.

Subscribe


Recent article comments

Powered by Disqus

Home arrow Opinion arrow Editorials arrow Spell-checkers: Good tools, lousy teachers

Print

Spell-checkers: Good tools, lousy teachers


Computers are marvelous tools — microchips helped put the words you’re reading on this page, for instance.

But computers are lousy spelling teachers.

Which is why we disagree with the Oregon Department of Education’s recent decision to allow seventh-graders and sophomores to use computer spell-checkers when they take state writing tests in January.

Our chief complaint is that spell-checkers entice students to bypass a crucial part of the writing process: proofreading.

And spell-checkers, though they’ll spot the transposed letters in “recieve” every time, will not rescue young writers (or old writers, come to that) from other pitfalls in the vast swamp of common errors.

Mistakenly use “there” when “their” was called for? Both look right to the computer. So do other common sets of homophones such as “two-too-to” and “won-one.”

Spell-checkers are equally useless in helping students deal with the vexing problem of where, or whether, to insert the comma.

We don’t mean to imply that the state’s spell-checker decision is a terrible scandal.

Spell-checkers are not evil. We use one every day (although, to our utter dismay, misspelled words still infect the paper, like bacteria).

But we’re not talking about people who write for a living. The issue is what’s the best strategy for teaching students the fundamentals of expressing themselves well on paper.

And spell-checkers, rather than instill those fundamentals, subvert them.

Student writers will misspell words and make other mistakes, of course.

But we prefer students learn to recognize those mistakes while carefully editing their own words, as opposed to relying on a computer.

The curious thing is that officials at the Department of Education agree with us.

Well, sort of.

Although the state will let seventh-graders and sophomores use computer spell-check programs during their writing tests, fourth-graders, who also take a writing test, are left out.

Those younger students have to rely on a dictionary or handheld spell-checker — neither of which, unlike a computer program, will find misspellings for you.

In other words, the state thinks fourth-graders will benefit from learning spelling the old-fashioned way, but students who are three to six years older won’t, or at least not as much.

Having read the work of seventh-graders and sophomores — and taking into account our own frustrating foibles — we disagree.

Print

blog comments powered by Disqus
News
Local / Sports / Business / State / National / Obituaries / Submit News
Opinion
Editorials / Letters / Columns / Submit a letter
Features
Outdoors / Go Magazine / Milestones / Living Well
Baker Herald
About / Contact / Commercial Printing / Subscriptions / Terms of Use / Privacy Policy / Commenting Policy / Site Map
Also Online
Photo Reprints / Videos / Local Business Links / Community Links / Weather and Road Cams / RSS Feed

Follow Baker City Herald headlines on Follow Baker City Herald headlines on Twitter

© Copyright 2001 - 2014 Western Communications, Inc. All rights reserved. By Using this site you agree to our Terms of Use